Developments in the Legal and Institutional Structure
It is not possible to describe the developments in the legal and institutional field during the Republican period and their consequences within the limits of this article. With this article, the aim has been to summarise the legal regulations made and the developments in the institutional structure in the field of nature conservation in Türkiye, in order to give an idea in the 100th year of our Republic.
Legal regulations in the field of nature conservation in Türkiye,
Many scientists and nature conservation experts accept that nature conservation in the sense we know it today began in 1872 with the declaration of “Yellowstone National Park”. The first national park in Europe was declared 37 years after America, in Sweden in 1909, and the second in Switzerland in 1914. In parallel with developments in the world, important regulations and developments have taken place in our country too, in both the legal and institutional fields, especially after the 1950s.
Although not in today’s sense, Article 10 of the Forest Planning Regulation issued in 1919 provided for setting aside and protecting part of the forests as protection forests. Later, the Land Hunting Law No. 3167, which came into force in 1937, brought regulation to land hunting.
The concept of the “National Park” was expressed for the first time in our country in the work “Doğa Koruma Karşısında Biz ve Ormancılığımız” (“We and Our Forestry in the Face of Nature Conservation”) published by Prof. Selahattin İnal in 1948. With the amendment made to Forest Law No. 6831 on 31.08.1956, the term “National Park” entered Turkish legislation. With this amendment, on the initiative of Zekai Bayer, a “National Parks Branch” was established within the General Directorate of Forestry, and the first legal and institutional foundations in the field of nature conservation were laid in our country. Based on Article 25 of the Forest Law, Yozgat Çamlığı National Park, the first national park of our country, was declared in 1958.
In 1983, three important legal regulations that hold an important place in the protection of our country’s nature were adopted by the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (TBMM). The first of these is the Law on the Conservation of Cultural and Natural Property No. 2863, which came into force on 21.7.1983. To date, 3,985 natural sites have been identified and registered on the basis of the Law on the Conservation of Cultural and Natural Property.
9 August 1983 was the day on which two important laws guiding Türkiye’s nature conservation were adopted by the TBMM. These are the Environment Law No. 2872 and the National Parks Law No. 2873.
With the National Parks Law, in addition to the “national park” status in Article 25 of Forest Law No. 6831, three important conservation statuses — “nature conservation area, nature park and natural monument” — entered our legislation, taking into account the nature conservation statuses proposed by the IUCN. The National Parks Law also made it possible to place areas outside the forest regime under protection.
As of 29 October 2023, there are 48 national parks, 31 nature conservation areas, 266 nature parks and 110 natural monuments. With the Land Hunting Law No. 4915, adopted on 01.07.2003, the Land Hunting Law No. 3167 was repealed; in addition to regulations on hunting, new regulations aimed at the protection of wildlife were introduced, and “wildlife protection areas and wildlife development areas” entered our legislation. There are 85 wildlife development areas in our country. Although defined in the legislation, there is no wildlife protection area.
With Environment Law No. 2872, the concept that the environment is the common asset of all living things entered our legislation. The law introduced regulations on the protection and improvement of the environment and the prevention of pollution. Since 1983, when the law came into force, many regulations have been issued on its implementation. Article 9 of the law contains important provisions on the protection of the environment, especially biodiversity, and on the international conventions signed for this purpose. Paragraph (d) of Article 9 provides for the identification and declaration of special environmental protection areas. 19 special environmental protection areas have been declared on the basis of the Environment Law.
Apart from the laws mentioned above, there are legal regulations in our national legislation containing many provisions that foresee the direct and indirect protection of the environment, nature and wildlife.
The Republic of Türkiye has become a party to almost all conventions opened for signature in the field of nature conservation. The “Convention for the Protection of Birds”, opened for signature in Paris on 18 October 1950, is the first international convention in this field. Türkiye approved this convention with Law No. 797 on 01 December 1966. Many conventions were signed in the 1980s and the following years. The main ones are:
• Barcelona Convention (Convention for the Protection of the Mediterranean Sea Against Pollution) Official Gazette Date: 12.06.1981 No: 17368
• Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage Official Gazette Date: 14.02.1983 No: 17959
• Bern Convention (Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife) Official Gazette Date: 20.02.1984 No: 18318
• Ramsar Convention (Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat) Date: 17.05.1994 No: 21937
• United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity Date: 27.12.1996 No: 22860
• CITES Convention (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) Date: 20.06.1996 No: 22672
• Bucharest Convention (Convention for the Protection of the Black Sea Against Pollution), protocol on the protection of biodiversity and landscape in the Black Sea Date: 06/07/2004 No: 25514
• Florence Convention (European Landscape Convention) Date: 27.07.2003 No: 25181
The last paragraph of Article 90 of the Constitution provides that “international agreements duly put into effect have the force of law. No appeal to the Constitutional Court can be made with regard to them on the grounds that they are unconstitutional.”
Development of the institutional structure in the field of nature conservation
When the concept of “national parks” entered our legislation in 1956 with the amendment to Forest Law No. 6831, a National Parks Branch was established within the General Directorate of Forestry, and two years later a National Parks Department. By 1976, for the first time a “General Directorate”-level structure was established under the Ministry of Forestry, the “General Directorate of National Parks and Hunting”, which continued its activities until 1982. In 1982 it was converted back into the Presidency of the National Parks Department under the General Directorate of Forestry; in 1991, with the re-establishment of the Ministry of Forestry, it was again raised to General Directorate level and restructured as the “General Directorate of National Parks and Hunting-Wildlife” under the Ministry of Forestry. The institution, which today works under the name General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks, began operating within the Ministry of Environment and Forestry in 2003 and, after 2018, with the merger of the Ministry of Forestry and the Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock and the adoption of the name Ministry of Agriculture, within that ministry.
Another important institution in the field of nature conservation in Türkiye is the General Directorate for the Protection of Natural Assets, which operates within the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change.
When the identification and declaration of Special Environmental Protection Areas was provided for in 1988 by Article 9 of the Environment Law, the Presidency of the Special Environmental Protection Agency, attached to the Prime Ministry, was established by Decree-Law No. 383 dated 19.10.1989 to manage these areas. The institution, which operated under this name for 19 years, was closed in 2018 and its duties were transferred to the General Directorate for the Protection of Natural Assets established within the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change.
Natural site areas, which were under the responsibility of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism until 2018, were also transferred to the General Directorate for the Protection of Natural Assets.
As summarised above, the institutions responsible for nature conservation in our country have undergone many changes since the day they were established. Unfortunately, this has negatively affected the development, institutionalisation and strengthening of the institutions and has also caused inadequacies in their fulfilling their duties and responsibilities.
Civil society organisations in the field of nature conservation
The first voluntary organisation related to nature conservation in Türkiye was the “Türkiye Tabiatını Koruma Derneği (TTKD)” (Turkish Association for the Conservation of Nature), established in 1955. The founding of TTKD dates to one year before the term national park entered our national legislation and the National Parks Branch was established within the General Directorate of Forestry.
The 1970s and after are important for civil society movements in our country. In particular, rapid population growth and migration from rural areas to cities and the resulting unplanned urbanisation, the use of modern agricultural machinery, pesticides and chemical fertilisers in agriculture, the increase and diversification of consumption needs, and, depending on all of these, the environmental problems that reached dimensions threatening all life; the opening of forest areas to infrastructure investments, settlements and mining, the conversion of pasture areas to agricultural land, the draining and pollution of wetlands, and the construction of hydroelectric power plants (HEPPs) on streams — problems such as these, as everywhere in the world, triggered the founding of many civil society organisations in our country both at the national level and at the local level. For example, in 1975, to protect the Northern Bald Ibis, most of which had died out in the 1970s because of wrong and excessive use of insecticide, the Doğal Hayatı Koruma Derneği (Society for the Protection of Wildlife) was established, which would carry out important work for Türkiye’s nature conservation.
In the following years, the Türkiye Çevre Vakfı (Environment Foundation of Türkiye) was established in 1978, the Türkiye Erozyonla Mücadele, Ağaçlandırma ve Doğal Varlıkları Koruma Vakfı (TEMA) in 1992, the Su Altı Araştırmaları Derneği (Underwater Research Society) in 1994, the Kuş Araştırmaları Derneği (Bird Research Society) in 1998, which would take the name Nature Research Society in 2011, and the Doğa Koruma Merkezi (Nature Conservation Centre) in 2004.
Today there are more than 1,000 civil society organisations working on the protection of the environment and nature. However, it is estimated that only about 400 of them are active. In the 2000s, against the construction of HEPPs on almost all streams and the mining operations spreading across almost every part of the country, civil society organisations also came together across the country to form platforms in order to combine their strength, take joint decisions and struggle together. Among these, the Türkiye Çevre Platformu (Environment Platform of Türkiye), established in 2005, the Ekoloji Birliği (Ecology Union), established in 2018, and the Empower the Nature Network (Doğaya Güç Kat Ağı), established in 2021, are platforms operating at the national level. Apart from these, there are many platforms that have come together at the local and regional level to struggle against environmental problems.
The nature conservation struggle that began in Türkiye under the leadership of civil society organisations has, over the last 30 years, evolved into civil reaction with the participation of local people in the struggles against HEPPs and against gold mining in Bergama, at Artvin Cerattepe, in the Kaz Mountains, in Fatsa and in Akbelen.
Despite the legal regulations and all the developments in the institutional structure, are we at the desired level in protecting our country’s natural values? Unfortunately, it is not possible to answer this question positively. There are a few main reasons for this. These are:
1. Fragmentation in the institutional structure: As stated above, there are two institutions in our country directly responsible for nature conservation. These are the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry – General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks, and the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change – General Directorate for the Protection of Natural Assets. The powers, duties and responsibilities in the field of nature conservation have been shared between these two general directorates almost as an inheritance is shared. This dispersion and fragmentation in the institutional structure, and the resulting lack of communication, cooperation and coordination between institutions, bring with them a serious confusion of authority and bureaucratic processes that are slow and sometimes even blocked; management plans that are prepared are not implemented, and as a result both human and financial resources are wasted.
2. The absence of a “Nature Conservation Law” that is free from contradictions and overlaps within our national legislation, is in harmony with international nature conservation conventions and will ensure their implementation at the national level.
3. The view of nature conservation: the fact that a considerable number of administrators in decision-making positions in our country see nature conservation as an obstacle to development,
4. The lack of qualified personnel and motivation in the public institutions responsible for nature conservation,
5. Problems in the relations between public institutions and civil society organisations.
References
Caner G., Ulusal ve Uluslararası Doğa Koruma Kriterleri ve Natura 2000, İstanbul, 2007
Yücel M., Babuş D., Doğa Korumanın Tarihçesi ve Türkiye’deki Gelişmeler, Doa Dergisi, 2005